I picked up a used Icom IC-F3161DT VHF portable
to play around with NXDN. In this thread I'll try pass on everything
I've learned about this radio, in the hope that it helps somebody else
who is considering a similar purchase.
I know the railways will
eventually be switching to NXDN, and I suspect that the BC Ministry of
Forests is also leaning that way. They have been planning on making the
switch to a digital mode for voice and data for a few years now, and I
know they use Kenwood and Icom gear. They COULD go with P25, but NXDN is
more-affordable. Whether or not anyone local to me actually ends up
using NXDN any time soon remains to be seen, but if they do, I'll
already have a capable radio and enough knowledge to be able to monitor
them. And NXDN seems to be an interesting mode for Amateur use as well.
Why
an Icom radio? I'm already familiar with Icom's programming software,
which is readily available. There's an Icom service center within an
hour from me. Icom gear has always been reliable for me. Used Icom gear
is relatively inexpensive. And it's a smart-looking unit, which has to
count for something!
They are are also reasonably rugged; they
pass all of the important MIL-STD specifications for rain, vibration,
shock, etc., and they have an Ingress Protection rating of IP55, which
means they're protected from dust (ingress of dust is not entirely
prevented, but it must not enter in sufficient quantity to interfere
with the satisfactory operation of the equipment) and water (water
projected by a nozzle (6.3 mm) against enclosure from any direction, for
a duration of at least 3 minutes, shall have no harmful effects).
Ratings from Wikipedia.
In
Icom terminology, "D" indicates that the digital module (UT-126H) is
installed, and "T" indicates the full keypad model. If you're
considering buying a used radio, definitely get the "D" model; adding a
UT-126H to a non-D can cost much more than buying a used "D", plus it
has to be "activated" by running a piece of software (available from
Icom).
When you're looking for a used Icom, you need to ensure
that the radio does not have the read/write password implemented (this
is separate from the user pw and the dealer pw). If it is, and you do
not have that password, the ONLY thing you can do is send the radio to
Icom Service to have the CPU replaced, at your cost. So stay away from
locked radios; ask before you buy.
There are two versions of the
F3161DT, the "regular" version and the "railroad" version. You can tell
which version you have by looking at the firmware revision. Hold down
the P0 and P3 buttons and turn the radio on; the display will show
something like "REV 3.1.1" if regular, or "REV 3.1.1 RR" if railroad.
Followed by a hex checksum, followed by the UT-126 revision, ie. "DREV
2.8", followed by another hex checksum. It turned out that I had the RR
version. I didn't know it was an RR version when I purchased the radio.
Note that the RR version requires different cloning software (CS) than
the standard version.
Now here's where things get interesting.
One would usually want to update the firmware to the latest version,
right? Not for Amateur use! Later firmware revisions have "force narrow"
enabled, which over-rides the programming setting in the radio. What
this means is that the later firmware forces the radio to use 12.5kHz
narrow-FM (NFM), even if you've programmed the channel for 25kHz FM. So
it would be essentially unusable for the analog non-narrow-FM Amateur
repeaters, or for talking with most Amateur (non-narrow-band compliant)
radios. I've read that the last 25kHz-friendly firmware revision is 4.1
(and 4.9 according to a different source). Note that there is an option
in the CS labelled "force narrow"; even if it's switched OFF, the
late-firmware radios will still only operate in NFM.
Interestingly,
Icom appears to have a "patch" available to qualified users (Amateur
Radio operators), which allows a late firmware-revision radio to use
25kHz FM. You are supposed to be able to send your .icf (clone file) to
Icom and they will edit it, and once you write it to your radio, you
will thereafter be able to use newer firmware revisions while still
retaining the 25kHz capability. However, I've also read that Icom won't
do this.
So what happens if you buy a radio with
less-than-desirable firmware? You can flash it with different firmware.
In my case, the firmware in the radio was 3.1.1 RR. I obtained
CS-F3160/F5060 RR version 4.6.3, and it worked perfectly with my radio.
Going through all of the options in the software showed that there were a
few options that could be enabled if I had newer firmware (version 4 or
newer), but they weren't anything I was interested in, so I am not
going to bother upgrading my firmware. Since I have not yet changed the firmware in one of these radios, I don't know the procedure.
If
you don't already have a programming cable, you should order one right
away. The cable needed is an OPC-966. I bought an aftermarket serial
(RS-232C) version from an eBay vendor in China for US$17 including
shipping to my door. It took just over a month to arrive via Airmail.
The reason I bought the serial version and not a USB version is because
all of the eBay ads for the USB version stated "will not work with a
64-bit operating system", and both my desktop and laptop computers are
running 64-bit Windows 7. And both have serial ports (bought
specifically BECAUSE they had serial ports). The USB cable comes with a
driver; the serial cable does not require a driver. I guess they don't
have a driver for 64-bit Windows. I used the default COM1 and everything
worked perfectly.
I should also mention that if you're looking
for the UHF version of this radio, the F4161DT is available in two band
splits, 400-470 MHz and 450-512 MHz. Obviously you'd want the 400-470
version for amateur use.
Also, there is a newer model of the
3161, the 3261. Since it's a new commercial radio, there is no reason
for it to have 25kHz FM, and it doesn't. So stick with the
less-expensive 3161 if you want to use 25 kHz FM.
RAILROAD FIRMWARE
The railroad (RR) firmware provides a method to directly-enter the AAR channel numbers for tx and rx, assuming you have a
"T"
model (full keypad). I am guessing that the RR firmware is only
available with the T models. There is a option to enable this in the CS.
Note: You can convert a non-RR F3161DT into an F3161DT RR. Details are further on in this thread, or here's the direct link to the post.
To
enter the AAR channels, when the radio is not scanning you can just
enter the tx and rx channel on the keypad. The method of entry depends
upon which of the three types of channels you want to use (wide, narrow,
or NXDN digital).
Note: You cannot enter Ch's 2-4 as they are grandfathered allocations only used in Canada, and not in the USA.
Channels 2-97 wide-band simplex: enter the 2-digit channel number and press "#", ie. 66#
Channels 2-97 wide-band duplex: enter the 2-digit tx and 2-digit rx channel numbers and press "#", ie. 6678#
Channels 2-196 narrow-band simplex: enter the 3-digit channel number and press "#" (enter the 2-digit channels with a leading "0"), ie. 066#, 120#
Channels 2-196 narrow-band duplex: enter the 3-digit tx and 3-digit rx channel number, ie. 066078
Channels 307-373 NXDN digital simplex: enter the 3-digit channel number and press "#", ie. 312#
Channels 307-373 NXDN digital duplex: enter the 3-digit tx and 3-digit rx channel number, ie. 312320
Your display will show the tx and rx channels, ie. T66R66 for simplex, or T306R312 for duplex.
If
you have the bandwidth indicator enabled, your display will show the
indicator for wide, narrow, or digital before the channel display, ie.
wT66R66, nT066R066, or dT306R312. I enabled mine; the only caveat with
doing this is you will lose the last character of your 12-character
alphanumeric display (for the non-AAR channels).
Edit: I later
disabled the bandwidth indicator as I found I didn't need it, and I
preferred having all 12 characters for alphanumeric tagging.
One
nice thing is that the AAR channels do not take up any of your
conventional memory channels. So despite having almost 300 AAR channels
built-in, you still have 512 conventional memory channels.
However,
because they are not part of your conventional memory channels, they
cannot be "scanned". If you want to scan RR channels, you will have to
place them in your conventional memory and add them to a scan list.
AAR channel list on RadioReference
The
RR version also provides a second bank of programmable keys. If you go
to "Common - Key & Display", under Key & Display Assign you will
see "Conventional (Bank 2)", where you can edit the secondary functions
of the P0-P4 buttons. In order to utilize the secondary bank,
immediately beneath Key & Display" you will see "Menu / Key Banks";
set "Menu Bank Access" to "Home/Bank2". So for me, my P4 (side 1) button
is set to "Menu", which toggles between the Home Bank and Bank2.
Whichever key is set to "Menu", it will be "Menu" for both banks (so you
can switch back). Mine are set to:
Home Bank
P0 - Scan Start/Stop
P1 - Scan Add/Del(Tag)
P2 - High/Low (power output)
P3 - Moni (monitor without tone or squelch)
Bank 2
P0 - Zone (toggles zones in banks of 16 if rotary knob is set to "Zone"; useful when you have more than 16 zones)
P1 - Talk Around
P2 - Surveillance (disables backlight and mutes beeps)
P3 - Tone/RAN CH Select
Note
that "Menu" requires a long press to switch between banks. A short
press will not do anything except switch on the backlight for 5 seconds
(as does any keypress), so instead of dedicating a button for "Light", I
just short-press the Menu button. This provides me with one additional
programmable option.
RELEVANT LINKS
Product info and specs
F3161/F4161 Instruction Manual (main)
F3161DT Instruction Manual (Railroad version)
F3161/F4161 Operating Guide (NXDN verions)
F3161/F4161 Instruction Manual (non-digital versions)
F3161/F4161 Instruction Manual (Factory Mutual Approved versions)
F3161/F4161 Instruction Manual - IDAS
F3161 Service Manual
F4161 Service Manual
This
is the SERIAL programming cable I bought. It works fine with my
Panasonic Toughbook and Intel Desktop, both of which have 9-pin RS-232C
serial ports. If you don't have a serial port, you'll need the USB
version, which I have not used.
Serial programming cable on eBay
Greg